She'd been violent before
Everything she says is a lie
Daniel made up that story
She was sick of him and felt drowned by his incompetence
You tell me! It’s a fictional story
She had a history of violence, the blood stains only made sense from contact somewhere else
Fallacies in her story, a dog theory doesn’t mean suicide. The blood splatter!!!!! Meddling with the witness! The kid’s fear of not having any parents!!! She’s a murderer!
Her autobiographical style of writing lends the murder a lot of poetic significance.
The prosecution left out her ability to push him out the window while we was working.
if i were a juror i would acquit because there is reasonable doubt but it takes for too much work to believe the suicide as opposed to the simpler murder. Sandra’s earlier claim to her lawyer that Samuel just fell is more believable to me!
Daniel made up the story about the dog, which echos what someone said about Sandra's books being part fiction and part real life.
god forbid women have hobbies
She was constantly lying with her eyes and body movements and just had a good lawyer
though my instincts are to trust women and mothers, and the film seemed to guide me to trust her, when she speaks in the car about winning and losing i lost my trust. i think Sandra got what she wanted without consequence, at least legal
I think she was much more violent and cunning. Biggest thing for me is we are taking her word on the fight and didn’t see it happen. He still seemed like a man that was fighting. I think he would have left her more so than killed himself
She's a writer and wanted material for her next book.
She's a writer and wanted material for her next book.
only thing that makes sense
the baseball from the start is missing, could be the killing weapon
Their relationship was too rocky before the incident. She had too many red flags.
Her story seemed inconsistent at times and it felt like her son was trying to change his story to help her.
She lied to prosecutors and her son lied to save her.
It’s a little difficult to imagine that even a blind child would forget they were outside listening to a conversation in the dead cold of winter
Gut feeling. Also blood spatter.
Boy made up story. Told himself a good night story. Boy wants mommy.
I think Daniel is reaching with that story at the end of the movie- I think it was simply about the dog, not himself
Her son thinks she did it and lied to protect her, which leads me to think she did it
because it’s more fun that way
too many coincidences! it was never explained why daniel called her a monster to his dad.
Physical violence in fights normal, frustration from the music, fight ends in her hitting him and he accidentally falls out of window
He never would have let his son find him.
She made up stuff as she went a long as did her son. Her son ran the experiment after he had already asked to re-testify, so what he was going to say orignally was different.
The dog had his eyes open in the final shot. Dogs are usually sleep with the eyes closed in a safe environment. Given that the dog’s eyes are open it implies that he is alert and protecting the son from the mom.
Because he wouldn’t kill himself like that
There’s reasonable doubt she did not do it of course. I don’t know what the burden of proof is in France. I don’t really trust Daniel’s testimony. I’m not at all confident, but I think that murder was more likely than suicide.
She killed that mf bruh idk what u want me to say
when i say yes, i mean she had helped into him milking himself because she made him miserable with the cheating and the fighting that’s all
Doesn’t matter if she did it physically, either way she drove him to it
Even if she didn’t physically attack him, she killed him by gaslighting him and invalidating his feelings. If he killed himself, she was a major contributing factor.
The argument from the day before
Because I decided she did
I think the son fabricated the story about the conversation with his father in the car which he believed would help the jury acquit his mother. Her story has too many holes in it. Guilty.
Daniel lied on her behalf
The dialogue scene outside of her and the lawyer where she compares people to animals. To me that confirms she was the one that gave the kid the speech that the dog could die any second was actually about her husband. She did it yall…
She either did it or it was an accident…no one is killing their self to P.I.M.P.
If this were supposed to be a movie i would say that the husband tried to frame her, but I think the real answer lies in her motive which is her need to be free from this relationship
she’s a wife killer….but she’s a woman. curious!!
feels like her son was lying to protect her
She kept “remembering” important relevant details after the fact. Daniel was scared for her to come home. Why/how could she sleep with the loud music. She was unsympathetic, self-centered and full of anger in recording.
고의는 아니었어도 결과적으로는 그녀가 죽였을 것
Wait? The only two ways possible are he committed suicide or I killed him? I just remembered he was suicidal.
samuel's death is not important. the death of their marriage is. one way or another, both of them are at fault.
The kid lied about what happened with his dad. So more likely she did it
She walked over the snow where her husband had died
I think they got in another fight the day of the fall, she hit him just in anger (not intending to kill) and he fell from the balcony.
pathological liar and storyteller creates fantasy to escape an unhappy life. that said, acquittal was correct. aren't courts wild?
It was a crime of passion. The story her son told about her husband preparing him for his eventual death was a fabrication.
Her story changes so much and it’s impossible to know the truth. I think her son chose to lie to save her so they could preserve whatever was left of their lives.
I think that he asked her to put him out of his misery. I believe that is why her feelings towards everything felt so complicated. Especially in the final shot when she goes to bed in the office and the dog joins her.
cus the bitch crazy and tell em Marcus said it
No note and given the locale there was surely a more effective method of suicide than jumping out a window.
When Daniel held her at the end, to me that was us learning that he had fabricated the story about his dad and him in the car.